both are good

saranac tastes more like pumpkin

Mitral valve replacement

banquet beer >

currently enjoying Sierra Nevada and some Murphy's stout

liquor >

my hate for you burns with the passion of a thousand suns

clearly really, because i know that you will never be truly happy you sad, pathetic motherfucker

i am unable to be anything but happy

the kracken spiced rum and vanilla coke.

also, miller high life.

girlfriend drinking sweedish fish flavored vodka

shit ain't bad BRAH

he keeps telling himself

and if i believe it, then what difference does it make

Southern Tier Pumking is the best pumpkin beer.

no no no

Someone must have peed in your beer

Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale is solid, but it's more of a spiced beer than a pumpkin beer. Dogfish Punkin Ale was so mediocre last year that my local beeratorium didn't even stock it this year. Heavy Seas Great Pumpkin was good last year, haven't had it yet this year. Sam Adams Pumpkin beer was good too.

http://beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/16289/62620

thats the best one ive had, personally
ive never had most of your fancy eastcoast pumpkin beers though

i dont like pumpkin beers

you afraid of them?

they just dont taste right to me

because most of them taste like pumpkin was added whenst bottling
imo

pumpkin ANYTHING will always taste bad in my experience. pumpkins included.

and use the beer sticky, it hasn't gotten love in 4 days

pumking gets too much attention and is clearly the "king" of pumpkin beers like many refer to it as. the last 2 times I tried it, it tasted like a hefeweizen with extra alcohol and spices added to it with little to no pumpkin flavor. the other ones you mentioned im pretty sure have little to no pumpkin even added to them, they just include the spices you typically associate with pumpkin. these are the kind of pumpkin beers that turn a lot of people away from them since most assume that pumpkin ale is all about the spices and doesn't even have pumpkin in them.

there are 3 pumpkin beers that stick out in my mind as being something I would continually purchase if made easily available. prior to trying these 3, I hated pumpkin beers because they were typically all spice and no pumpkin flavor

midnight sun: treat (this is like a hybrid porter mixed with pumpkin)
selinsgrove: pumpkin ale
iron hill: pumpkin ale

the last 2 on that list use dessert pumpkins in excessive quantity and you really get that rich pumpkin flavor with a very minimal amount of spice

obligatory rock arts brewery imperial spruce pumpkin stout poop

I can clearly get any of those in Connecticut If I can get any of them in NY I'll call around and try to grab them next weekend because I'll be almost in NY anyway.

Pumking doesn't taste anything like you describe it, so I guess we have really different tastes in that regard.

I thought I had a bad bottle until I had it again on tap and thought the exact same thing.
All cloves with like a shot of vodka added.

do you really like it that much or are you teasing me?