Desolate Carnage
 
@ Adam
Archived | Views: 1275 | Replies: 21 | Started 13 years, 4 months ago
 
#804426 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 09:06:28
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
coffee
work
home
tf2

bye bro
 
#804427 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 09:47:04
Group: Members
Posts: 60,63040k
Joined: Aug 30 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 75,457.20
coffee
minecraft
trivia
wine
 
#804429 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 10:15:54
Group: Members
Posts: 47,60340k
Joined: Sep 1 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 44,538.17
growlers for tomorrow:
pliny the elder
black butte 23
hop in the dark
switchback stout

bottles:
slap yo mammy
stop making sense
kriek 2010



will update this as i remember and look around for more
 
#804447 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:12:54
Group: Members
Posts: 26,99320k
Joined: Aug 30 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 1,959.57
you got pliney?

isnt that like #1 ipa in the world
 
#804448 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:42:02
Group: Members
Posts: 27,88820k
Joined: Aug 31 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 381.50 $
coors light
 
#804450 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:53:53
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
Quote (___ @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 14:12:54)
you got pliney?

isnt that like #1 ipa in the world


I had the elder once and imo blue dot and dreadnaught were both better.
 
#804453 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:57:14
Group: Guest
Posts: 14,41410k
Joined: Oct 2 2007
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 1,162.65
Quote (Sgull @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 09:47:04)
coffee
minecraft
trivia
wine


clearly the highlight
 
#804454 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 17:05:01
Group: Members
Posts: 47,60340k
Joined: Sep 1 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 44,538.17
Quote (blind_chief @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:53:53)
Quote (___ @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 14:12:54)
you got pliney?

isnt that like #1 ipa in the world


I had the elder once and imo blue dot and dreadnaught were both better.


I think dreadnaught on tap and really fresh is amazing, same with elder tho...blue dot is p delicious...but ranking bottles I would say dreadnaught, blue dot, elder

on tap, elder, dreadnaught, blue dot (never had)
 
#804457 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 18:18:49
Group: Members
Posts: 32,34230k
Joined: May 31 2007
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 3,155.70
Quote (___ @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:12:54)
you got pliney?

isnt that like #1 ipa in the world


Pliny is really overrated. It's a damn good beer all around, but it isn't the holy grail. It might be based on freshness, but I think Gandhi-bot is better.
 
#804459 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 19:36:54
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
Quote (Zodijackyl @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:18:49)
Quote (___ @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 16:12:54)
you got pliney?

isnt that like #1 ipa in the world


Pliny is really overrated. It's a damn good beer all around, but it isn't the holy grail. It might be based on freshness, but I think Gandhi-bot is better.


i think age is everything with pliny. i had a 6 week old one and it had nowhere near the fruityness of blue dot or dreadnaught. it was just an excellent pine-y ipa. but living in the hophead nw ive had plenty of ipas that can compete. though im getting those extra fresh and clearly the pliny, so its all relative imo.
 
#804460 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 19:37:30
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
blue dot is still too inconsistent with the carb but that grapefruit flavor omnomnom
 
#804461 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 19:57:40
Group: Members
Posts: 50,46540k
Joined: Mar 29 2008
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 9,628.10 $ $
I think you are getting pliny the younger and pliny the elder confused.

Pliny the younger at 3 days old was the single best beer I have ever experienced in my life. Pliny the elder is good but suffers horrific instability. On draft it is pretty good, out of a bottle that is only 2 weeks old it is clearly as good as Dreadnaught at a month or more old.
 
#804462 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 20:16:38
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
Quote (xstakemx @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 17:57:40)
I think you are getting pliny the younger and pliny the elder confused.

Pliny the younger at 3 days old was the single best beer I have ever experienced in my life. Pliny the elder is good but suffers horrific instability. On draft it is pretty good, out of a bottle that is only 2 weeks old it is clearly as good as Dreadnaught at a month or more old.


who are you talking too?
 
#804466 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 20:38:28
Group: Members
Posts: 50,46540k
Joined: Mar 29 2008
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 9,628.10 $ $
Sorry was meant to be at Gary since he mentioned the whole #1 ipa in the world thing.
 
#804467 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 20:53:36
Group: Members
Posts: 74,19840k
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,883.75 $ $
Quote (xstakemx @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 18:38:28)
Sorry was meant to be at Gary since he mentioned the whole #1 ipa in the world thing.


elder is still hyped up to be #3 overall
i just dont get it, maybe one day!
 
#804468 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 20:59:06
Group: Members
Posts: 50,46540k
Joined: Mar 29 2008
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 9,628.10 $ $
Quote (blind_chief @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:53:36)
Quote (xstakemx @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 18:38:28)
Sorry was meant to be at Gary since he mentioned the whole #1 ipa in the world thing.


elder is still hyped up to be #3 overall
i just dont get it, maybe one day!


I blame that on California and all the people in it.
I will also argue that while Ghandi bot is good, it isn't a favorite of mine.
 
#804469 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:05:10
Group: Members
Posts: 32,34230k
Joined: May 31 2007
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 3,155.70
With the freshest IPAs, it must be hard to compare. I have a bias towards the east coast due to availability and freshness, but the west coast classics like SN and Anchor tend to be really good even if they are older. The CT distribution system means it is faster to get beers mailed from the west coast than to wait for them to be approved. Most of the WC beers I have enjoyed were brought in from other states.

Still, I think NEBCO beats everyone else with Gandhi-bot, Citra-hopped Sea Hag, and the dry hopped Alpha Weizen. CCBC also overwhelms the reasonably-priced IPA market even though the price has risen from $8-11 6pk/12oz. I wouldn't pay an insane price for Pliny when I can get Gandhi-bot for $15 for a growler or $11/4pk.
 
#804471 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:17:14
Group: Members
Posts: 50,46540k
Joined: Mar 29 2008
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 9,628.10 $ $
As far as canned hoppy beers go, I would take Half acre's daisy cutter pale ale or anything hoppy from Surly over Gandhi bot. Dan has provided me multiple opportunities to have it about as fresh as it is possible and I still think it falls short of what others are producing.

The best hoppy beers on the east coast, hands down come from Hill Farmstead. Ephriam gives Pliny the younger a run for it's money and their single hop version of Galaxy Imperial IPA is pretty unreal.

This is pretty much an endless conversation, we could go on and on. It is all a matter of reference and "have you had this or that" comparison.
 
#804472 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:18:26
Group: Members
Posts: 11,32610k
Joined: Sep 1 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 2,118.11 $
i prefer a bowl of hops plus milk
 
#804473 | Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:22:56
Group: Members
Posts: 50,46540k
Joined: Mar 29 2008
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 9,628.10 $ $
Quote (bubbachunk @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 22:18:26)
i prefer a bowl of hops plus milk


i am downright amazed you didnt bring hopslam or oracle into this conversation
well done
 
#804497 | Fri - Aug 12 2011 - 05:24:51
Group: Members
Posts: 11,32610k
Joined: Sep 1 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 2,118.11 $
Quote (xstakemx @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 21:22:56)
Quote (bubbachunk @ Thu - Aug 11 2011 - 22:18:26)
i prefer a bowl of hops plus milk


i am downright amazed you didnt bring hopslam or oracle into this conversation
well done


best ones I have had access to
 
#804500 | Fri - Aug 12 2011 - 07:44:34
Group: Guest
Posts: 18,48810k
Joined: Sep 1 2006
Contact: Offline PM
Points: 6,611.60
on the road to 20k
Archived | Views: 1275 | Replies: 21 | General Archive Topic List
 
Quit the Internet